Research body BSRIA has warned that the aims of the £13.2 billion Warm Homes Plan are being put at risk by a failure to properly measure and validate the measures post-occupancy.
Recent findings from the testing and research authority found that that despite 97% of construction professionals agreeing that occupant behaviour plays a defining role in whether retrofits deliver operational efficiency, the vast majority are failing to measure or validate outcomes post-handover.
In the survey three quarters (76%) of construction professionals said that they do not prioritise post-occupancy evaluations (POEs).
For both retrofit projects and new build developments, POEs are crucial to identify discrepancies between intended outcomes and real-world use, BSRIA said:
POEs enable adjustments that improve building performance while simultaneously supporting people in running their homes, or other buildings, efficiently to maximise indoor environmental quality and energy savings.
Illustrating the importance of such evaluation, BSRIA’s research found that 55% of consumers are unfamiliar with what ‘retrofit’ means and only 31$ of homeowners believe that ‘retrofit will reduce energy use’.
BSRIA pointed to recent research by the University of East London, which found that buildings are acutely affected by occupant behaviour – indicating a difference between predicted building performance and measured output of as much as 300%. This demonstrates how failing to embed occupant engagement and education into the handover process can leave retrofit work at risk of severe performance shortfalls, which can significantly erode energy efficiency and comfort, said Tom Garrigan, Executive Director at BSRIA (pictured above).
He said:
For housebuilders and developers, the handover of a retrofitted home can’t be the end of the story: implementing measures alone is not enough. Performance issues emerge when occupants don’t fully understand low-carbon systems and indoor environmental controls, leading to higher running costs and missed targets. While there has been progress in some areas of the market, it’s critical that the wider industry prioritises occupant education to ensure that homes work for people in practice, not just on paper.
He added that the problem extends to newbuild projects too:
With the Future Homes Standard approaching, residents in both new builds and refurbished buildings will require greater support to confidently manage longer heating cycles, responsive controls, and new approaches to comfort and efficiency. Investing in robust post-retrofit evaluations and support will help to close the gap between design ambition and real-world results. This means that occupant education must be integral to the retrofit journey, to ensure that the fabric improvements made will contribute to achieving Net Zero not just at point of installation, but for the long-term.
He noted that BSRIA will continue to champion this approach through ‘research, training and demonstrator projects that showcase retrofit leadership for the industry.’
- Use of data in evaluating buildings is one of the many subjects to be discussed at elementalLONDON on 19-20 November.
