Spotlight on standards, competence and the human impact of buildings, with BESA chief executive David Frise.
My conversation with David Frise comes at a pretty pivotal moment for the association that represents the building engineering services sector.
For while I am here principally to discuss BESA’s brace of initiatives around competence and compliance – designed both to underline collective responsibility, in the case of the Client’s Guide to the Building Safety Act, and to underscore the capability of its members to deliver the Act, via the BESA Member Pledge – my interview coincides with developments that are nothing short of seismic in the world of the specialist contractor.
The government’s promise of radical reform to late payment, including an end to construction retentions is genuinely, of massive significance. In construction, the withholding until the end of a project of a proportion of a contractor’s fee, aka a retention, is a vehicle that has been argued against for decades by those often-smaller companies who are disadvantaged by it – and resisted with equal effort by those often-larger companies who have benefited from it.
The promise of an end to retentions is, to the specialist contractor, a Very Big Deal, David confirms:
“I think I’ve personally been campaigning on retentions for 35 years,” he reflects, “What retentions and poor payment practice really does is it steals your time, and that’s time you can’t spend on doing the things that actually make a difference.”
However, he emphasises that we are not yet at the end to retentions – more like the beginning of the end:
“That’s why it’s essential that we continue to keep the pressure on,” he says, “To make sure firstly that the legislation goes through, but secondly to ensure that the industry isn’t allowed to get around it.”
And there are those already trying to get around it. He has no time for those who have argued that holding onto retentions is the best way to guarantee against defects: “When did retentions really ever help deliver a defect-free building? The answer is not to hold onto money but to procure better. Procure from a supply chain you trust and who you know will deliver a defect-free building.”
On top of that, he notes, there is now a requirement under the Building Safety Act to procure for competence and compliance and safety: “You’d be held liable if you turned a blind eye to a problem in your supply chain – actually you’ve got to take far more responsibility for your supply chain and what’s happening down there, because there is what the consultant Mark Farmer describes as only ‘a thin patina of compliance’ in this industry.”
The challenge of enforcing the Act
One of the challenges with the progress of the Building Safety Act is that there are still clients procuring on the basis that the Act has nothing to do with them, David notes – which is why BESA brought out its Client’s Guide.
“It’s designed to enable contractors to give it to the client and say, ‘You can’t delegate responsibility for that. You own it and you’re going to own it and there is liability that attaches to you,’” he says, “But it won’t really kick in until the industry has changed to such an extent that they actually understand how the Act operates and then you really get into ‘design and build’ as opposed to the ‘build and design’ model that many still seem to use.”
Visible enforcement is the only thing that will really change behaviour, he says – when people recognise ‘that could be me’ in the headlines around prosecutions.
Addressing the industry’s shortage of skills
That brings him onto another pressing matter for the construction industry and BESA: skills shortages: “Every sector has skills shortages and it’s not hundreds of people, it’s not thousands, it’s tens of thousands of people who are required. And many of these are contradictory requirements, aren’t they? You’re short of people, but you don’t want more migration. So it comes down to what compromises you are willing to make.”
Alongside making migrant labour easier to access, at least in the short term, the key matter is attracting young people into the industry – an issue in the US and Europe as much as it is in the UK. However, he does think that this is changing: “I think now parents look at construction and allied industries and go, ‘We need to make sure that our kids are going into an AI-proof industry,’” he says.
There has been something like $100 million of funding channelled into training of mechanical trades in the US by investor Blackrock, he notes, ‘because they need the data centres, they need the chip factories.’
The building engineering sector offers particular opportunity for apprentices to progress, he stresses: “You can go on to become a chartered engineer. You can become a director of a major company. So many of the people in the M&E sector who are now running big companies started as apprentices – they worked their way through the ranks.”
Changing the image of construction
He points to the typical experience of the public towards ‘construction’: “Pretty low quality; pretty short on safety standards; and a waste skip being changed at 6am” and notes it is worlds away from what a buildings specialist contractor does, because the high-value stuff is so often hidden behind hoardings.
And don’t get him started on the use of ‘plumber’ as an onsite catch-all to describe the work his mechanical services members do: “The stereotype is a guy or girl who’s just done your mum’s bathroom. But equally, I’m a plumber and I worked on submarines. You could then go all the way up to Hinckley power station, show a pipefitter and say, ‘Well, they’re a plumber too.’ So perhaps we need to reclaim the term for the mechanical trades – ‘plumber’ is, after all, far better known than ‘pipefitter’.”
For David, improving the industry in the round could open the door to a wealth of benefits: “While you’re chasing payment or you’re chasing retentions, you are not improving your business. You haven’t got the working capital to invest in the apprentices. If it’s an industry that’s more attractive because it’s a better industry, then you get more people wanting to be in and retain people.”
This, in turn, will create a virtuous circle, stemming from those higher standards brought about by the Building Safety Act, he says:
“I do believe that the Building Safety Act will drive greater competence and compliance, although it’s not going to happen overnight. But that will see the process of design and build replacing build and design. In turn, the industry will become more based more on assembly rather than construction, because the building has been designed digitally already and often largely manufactured offsite.”
But, importantly, he says, it will help to address another issue that the industry creates far too often – overrunning: “Construction is too good at turning a 24-week project into a 48-week project (it has to be said often not our fault), so they’re still there changing the skip at six in the morning, disrupting the public and impacting all the businesses around them for longer. But with all the above improvements in place, contractors can then get a reputation for delivering projects to a very high quality that work and are on time. And thus you’re a better industry, which inevitably is more attractive to join for a career.”
Raising the standards – of contractors and beyond
Standard-setting is very much a key element of the new compliance-focused regime and BESA is determined to lead the way for its members. It has long had in place independent audits of its members, but, and recently it upped the ante, with the launch of its Member Pledge, which demonstrate to clients and others the contractor’s competence and compliance at both an organisational level and at an individual level.
“We sat down with our council and told them that as they are the leading companies in the industry, it was time to show some leadership and change the things that they can control – and then to challenge the industry to come up to their standards.” he says.
Another consequence of raising standards, David stresses, is that those who don’t make the grade are suspended from membership. In the last year, some 20 companies have faced this sanction. Several of these have subsequently raised their game and successfully reapplied, he notes.
This focus on competence throughout a business is going to become ever-more important too, he believes:
“There’s no way that that such demonstrations of capability are getting rowed back on as far as I can see. If only because I think eventually insurers will wake up to the fact that if you can’t evidence that capability, you’re a poor insurance risk.”
“Can you do the job?”
It’s something that David gets pretty passionate about, for good reason, he says, because construction, for all its paperwork, doesn’t always ask the right questions:
“There are endless prequalification processes for construction projects, but out of the 400-odd PQ questions, there is not one that says, ‘Can you do the job?’ Having proper employment contracts and all of those kind of things is all very well. But whether you can do the job is surely the critical one. Can you strangle pipework into a plantroom? And therefore, we think we’re the only body at the moment that asks those critical technical questions.”
Simply put, by putting the specialist contractors’ house in order, BESA believes that it can influence those they work with – that a rising tide will raise all boats:
“What we’re trying to do is get to a position where our members can say, ‘We can evidence our competence and compliance and where appropriate, our supply chain is also compliant.’ This will take years to bring into place, but you have to sort out your own sector before you can demand it of others.”
The aim is also to drive the Members’ Pledge down into the supply chain, so that specialist sub-contractors sign up to become BESA members too.
And importantly, the process is gaining traction, he believes: “I do think we are getting to is a position where we say, ‘We dare you to specify non-BESA members for your job.’ Because if it all goes Pete Tong, someone will ask ‘Why didn’t you specify a contractor that passed a third-party accredited technical audit?’”
And, he points out, BESA’s Client’s Guide to the Building Safety Act is also a key element in the quest for higher standards: “The client has responsibilities. And engineering services are more than 50% of their work. So you would say to that client: ‘How do you know that the contractor you have subcontracted the package to is competent?’ The way the client can discharge their duty of care – as can the main contractor – is by selecting a BESA member.”
The vital contribution of building engineering services
Why does this all matter so much? Because the building engineering services industry doesn’t draw attention to itself, but what it does is vital:
“When it works, nobody even notices. You’re not hot, you’re not cold, you don’t feel it, you can’t hear it, you can’t smell it. But when it doesn’t work, you know about it – but it’s difficult to value something that you don’t know. If you just walk around any city now, the built environment is really, really important to us – 90% of us spend 90% of our time in a building, and yet we allow quite a lot of it to be built really speculatively by a developer who then disappears. And we also fail to maintain it. The backlog on the NHS maintenance is now nearly £16bn – it’s the same in schools.”
Lest we should still be underestimating the importance of this work, David underlines the real-world consequences: “That lack of hospital maintenance means that your surgery may be delayed or cancelled – not because they haven’t got the people to do it, but because the ventilation system isn’t working.”
This, he points out, also has a very real bearing on the energy security and climate issues that are weighing so heavily on the government currently: “If you want to help mitigate the climate crisis, then remember that half of carbon emissions come from buildings and their operations and therefore you need to build systems that work as designed and that deliver. If they don’t deliver, we have to go and build more power plants and generate more energy. And therefore investing in efficient buildings should be seen as necessary as defence!”
And if the economic argument around better buildings doesn’t convince you, David concludes, you should consider the human impact: “Buildings have an enormous impact on physical and mental wellbeing – isn’t it obvious? You go to any city in the world, and you will see beautiful places that have been created by really talented architects and engineers – they uplift the spirit.”
The counterpoint to that, of course, he adds, are those squalid apartments which have mould in them or water that’s leaking: “It’s no wonder that they make people physically and mentally ill. I don’t think we take that into account enough. We talk about UK plc and we build HS2 and projects like that. But perhaps if we had we’ve invested that money in physically improving our schools or social housing or hospitals, the benefit would have been far, far greater. Our ability to produce; to learn; our wellbeing; it all improves if the built environment actually works.”
- BESA is a partner with elementalLONDON on 25-26 November
